The debate between furnaces and heat pumps is a common one, but is one really better for homeowners in Semmes, Alabama? They will both heat your home, but they do so through different methods, and a heat pump has the advantage of providing cooling as well. Size, features, efficiency, and cost are also important factors. Deciding whether or not a furnace or heat pump is best for your home comes down to making an informed decision based on system performance and your needs. You will need to consider how both furnaces and heat pumps work, and the pros and cons of each.

Conventional Furnace

A conventional HVAC furnace works with a duct system to get warm air to various rooms in your home. To generate heat, a furnace burns fuel (often natural gas, but sometimes oil). These heated gases then pass through a heat exchanger in coils. Air from your home blows over these heat exchanger coils, heating up the air, and then redistributing it through your home via the duct system.

Furnace Pros

  • Reliability: Over the years, furnaces have been designed to be more efficient and to provide the right levels of heating comfort.
  • Durability: Modern systems are being designed to be more durable. With proper use and maintenance, they can last much longer than older model furnaces. They also last much longer than heat pumps and require less maintenance. They can also withstand the rigors of unpredictable winters.
  • Performance: Furnaces provide better heating performance and are ideal for regions that see harsh winters. A heat pump doesn’t work as well in extreme temperatures.

Furnace Cons

  • Risk: Even though furnaces today are built to be safer and more efficient, there is always the risk of a carbon monoxide leak. This risk can be minimized with regular maintenance and replacing old or damaged furnaces. Carbon monoxide detectors in your home are very important.
  • Efficiency: Although modern systems have greatly improved in performance, a heat pump can still save you more on your energy bills.
  • Air Quality: From the combustion of gases to the system of ductwork, central heating systems can have a greater negative impact on your indoor air quality than a heat pump.

Heat Pumps

In contrast to a forced-air system, a heat pump moves rather than produces air. Warm air is moved out of the home in the hot months, and into the air outside. A heat pump can also function in the reverse, cycling in warm air while cycling out the cool air during the winter months.

A heat pump consists of both an indoor unit and outdoor condensing unit. Heat pumps are known for efficiency since they don’t expend the energy or fuel to produce their own heat.

Heat Pump Pros

  • Efficiency: Since a heat pump doesn’t rely on fuel and just moves air around, it saves you a considerable amount on the utility bill. You also get heating and cooling in one unit.
  • Installation Cost: It costs less to install a heat pump since it doesn’t need the ventilation system a furnace requires.
  • Safety: Without the risk of carbon monoxide leaks, a heat pump is safer for your home.

Heat Pump Cons

  • Effectiveness: Since a heat pump only moves air, it doesn’t have the power of a furnace and won’t function as well in extremely cold regions.
  • Supplemental Heating: A heat pump may require additional heating support when it can’t provide sufficient warmth.
  • Maintenance: Split between two units, the heat pump may require more maintenance than a conventional furnace.

The Verdict

Both a heat pump and furnace can provide warmth in the winter. A heat pump, however, can cool your home during the hot summer months. Even if you consider cost and efficiency, the system that works best for your home will depend on the unique conditions of your home and region.

It is a good idea to consult your HVAC technician who will consider factors such as the size of the home, the number of occupants, and the typical weather conditions of the area to determine the best system.

The pros at Air Speciality, Inc. can help you to make the best decision according to your needs and budget. Whatever decision you make, we also provide the right systems and installation solutions. Call us today at 251-545-3337 with your furnace or heat pump questions. We look forward to serving your HVAC needs.

Image provided by Shutterstock

Carrier FAD NATE Certified BBB 24/7 Emergency Services